Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Which Selina Kyle/Catwoman ? ... Tim Burton/Pfieffer or ChrisNolan/Hathaway ? 

243 deviants said Anne Hathaway ( The Dark Knight Rises )
229 deviants said Michelle Pfieffer ( Batman Returns )

Devious Comments

LanaMarieLive Featured By Owner Jul 29, 2012  Professional General Artist
I like both ladies, but the Tim Burton/Michelle style will always have a place in my heart. I actually just uploaded my Hathaway Catwoman inspired cosplay & Currently upgrading my Tim Burton Catwoman Cosplay ;)
Anthropix Featured By Owner Jul 28, 2012  Professional Photographer
Honestly when I found out Anne Hathway was playing catwoman I was a little disappointed but she actually worked out great as an addition to the nolan batman movies, she rocked a bad ass hot attitude I agree with that Julie Newmar approach. Michelle's performance as catwoman still is creepier and sexier to me though so she has my vote. Michelle just showed soo much more character iono itd be pretty hard to top that i think
ZazMan Featured By Owner Jul 27, 2012
just saw, TDKR, i wasn't liking the idea of Anne Hathaway as Catwoman, I didn't think she could do the role, but WOW, less then 2 minutes after she caught by BW, I was sold on the idea. The girl got skillz, that all i can say. Michelle Pfieffer did a good job, but i was never sold on Tim Burtton vision of the character, but I like the look. Julie Newmar to me is the best Catwoman on TV/film, and i like how Anne Hathaway pay tribute to Julie Newmar's Catwoman. Anne Hathaway, blew me away as Catwoman I didn't think she could be believeable in the role, She prove me wrong! on top of that, I haven't been a fan of the Nolan Films! TDKR is the BEST of the bunch! well, in my Opinion
endormoon Featured By Owner Jul 26, 2012
Having seen both movies in the past month i would have to go with Anne Hathaway hands down. I think Nolan's version is a great blend of the modern and the classic and it holds truer to the comic books.
AkhMorn Featured By Owner Jul 25, 2012
I think Michelle Pfeiffer is a very iconic, fun Catwoman, but I think Nolan/Anne's Catwoman was more representative of Selina as a sane cat burglar instead of an unhinged cat lover.
vera-baby Featured By Owner Jul 22, 2012
Michelle was my favorite, didn't think she could be topped.. but I was blown away by Anne. I thought she would be good, but I had no idea how perfect for the role she would be
insolitus85 Featured By Owner Jul 22, 2012  Hobbyist Photographer
I vote Halle Berry :D
RobertDobolinaEsq Featured By Owner Jul 22, 2012
I think Hathaway blew the doubters absolutely out of the water as Catwoman, frankly. It was even predictable that she would: people looked at her chick-flick resume and dismissed her, but it was clear to me that she had the charisma and ability to pull it off. Pfeiffer was great as a fetishy sex symbol, but Hathaway made Catwoman into a better and more believable *character* without losing her sultry side.
KXZXW Featured By Owner Jul 22, 2012
Wow 148 to 147 Pfieffer in the lead. Was not expecting that. I'm not a batman fan or anything but I don't think cat woman is a believable role for Anne Hathaway.
Aexalven Featured By Owner Jul 21, 2012
Hathaway is ugly and she's terribad as catwoman
BorjaMendez Featured By Owner Jul 21, 2012  Professional Photographer
I prefer Pfieffer's, but she has more time to develop the character. Anne Hathaway can't make the character so deep and changing because her presence is almost anecdotic leaving more space to Bane
xxmalxx Featured By Owner Jul 21, 2012  Professional Photographer
I prefer Anne Hathaway's version of cat woman. Much more interesting character than Michelle Pfieffer's.
echic10 Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012  Professional Photographer
I just see MP's characterization of Catwoman as being a declawed indoor cat. Of course Julie Newmar set the mark to which all others aspire.

Anne Hathaway FTW!
XiahouDun Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012
Anne Hathaway. A million times Anne Hathaway
chuckiebobphil Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012  Professional Artist
Julie Nomar or Eartha Kit were the best
iRobathon Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I haven't seen the Dark Knight Rises, which is a good thing since there was a massacre in the theater last night, but I'm going to vote Anne Hathaway. Michelle Pfieffer was good, really good, but I think Anne Hathaway could give her a run for her money. So I'm placing my faith in her acting ability.
PerforatedPhoto Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012
I think MP has the Catwoman title... In my mind she has the sex appeal + slightly unhinged + Internal Good/Evil Struggle going on...
RaziyaRodriguez Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I personally prefer Anne Hathaway as Catwoman because she came the closest to the Julie Newmar version, which is in my opinion, the original and only true Catwoman.
Delacrux Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012
Im sure Anne Hathaway fine in that movie but the best Catwoman (in movies/tv shows) in Michelle Pfeiffer. Hands down. It's just everytime i see her i think of all those chickflicks she's been in and makes it so unbelieveable to see her as Selina Kyle/Catwoman.
sideshowsito Featured By Owner Jul 20, 2012  Professional Photographer
I think Anne Hathaway was great as catwoman in TDKR ... but personally I still think Michelle Pfieffer holds the title as Catwoman ^_^
Add a Comment:

Poll History